Who Is The Best Creed Virgin Island Water Clone NOW? Discover The Top 5!
Creed Virgin Island Water is known for its tropical allure, evoking serene beaches and refreshing breezes.
Yet, at $400, it’s not reasonable for everyone to own a bottle.
Below, I have the top clones for quality and replication. Read about them all and find the best one for you.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Yet, we only endorse fragrances we’ve personally used or are highly recommended by trusted peers. You can learn more about our Disclaimer & Disclosure here.
Table of Contents
What Does Creed Virgin Island Water Smell Like?
Price: $345 – $1205 USD
Bottle Sizes: 50mL, 100mL, 250mL & 500mL
Top Notes: Bergamot, Lime, Tropical Fruits
Middle Notes: Coconut Milk, Coconut Water, Jasmine, White Florals
Base Notes: Tonka Bean, White Musk
*Notes, price, and bottle sizes were all pulled from the official Creed website.
Scent Profile: An authentic and powerful citrus opening leads to a smooth coconut background. After about 15 minutes, the coconut note becomes more prominent, accompanied by subtle rum nuances.
The booziness is fleeting, resulting in occasional wafts throughout the wear. The scent blends into a clean, tropical aroma with coconut rum and a musky background.
Performance: Virgin Island Water lasts around six hours on the skin with intimate projection. It maintains a light ambiance, pushing out up to a foot.
Occasions: Exclusively summer wear, ideal for casual occasions due to its light and tropical nature.
Malibu – Party in the Bay by Simone Andreoli
Price: $189 USD
Bottle Sizes: 100mL
Top Notes: Lime, Green Accord
Middle Notes: Coconut Nectar, Sugar
Base Notes: Rum, Sandalwood
Scent Profile: Lime and coconut with a subtle rum note, clean green middle, and smooth woody depth. It ultimately resembles Virgin Island Water but with a smooth, woody note, adding delicate depth.
It is one of the better clones because of its high quality and close replication.
Performance: Six-hour longevity with two to three feet projection initially.
Price: Higher priced but excellent quality and resemblance.
Hawaii Volcano by Alexandria Fragrances
Price: $45 – $110 USD
Bottle Sizes: 30mL, 55mL, 60mL & 100mL
Top Notes: Lime, Coconut, Sicilian Bergamot, Sicilian Mandarian
Middle Notes: Ylang-ylang, Indian Jasmine, Hibiscus
Base Notes: Musk, Woody Notes
Scent Profile: Lime and creamy coconut without the boozy rum. It ends with a woody depth not found in Virgin Island Water. Hawaii Volcano is always subtle and never overpowering.
Performance: Lasts seven hours with moderate projection.
Price: Affordable, dynamic alternative for casual summer wear.
Gorse by Laboratory Perfumes
Price: $90 USD
Bottle Sizes: 100mL
Top Notes: Bergamot, Coconut, Lime, Lemon, Mandarin, Ginger, Cardamom
Middle Notes: Jasmine, Ylang-ylang, Lily of the Valley
Base Notes: Musk, Amber, Milky
*Notes, price, and bottle sizes were all pulled from the official Gorse website.
Scent Profile: This fragrance starts with a citrus-heavy beginning but lacks the intense lime of Virgin Island Water. Instead, it features a stronger coconut note and rum nuances, with noticeable spices that Virgin Island Water only subtly hints at.
After a few hours, it settles to closely resemble the scent of Virgin Island Water.
Performance: Eight to nine hours with light projection.
Price: Higher-end option with prominent coconut notes.
Caribbean Water by The Dua Brand
Price: $55 USD
Bottle Sizes: 34mL
Notes: Bergamot, Lime, Mandarin, Coconut, Sugar Cane, White Rum
*Notes, price, and bottle sizes were all pulled from the official Dua Brand website.
Scent Profile: Almost a 1:1 match with Virgin Island Water but with a synthetic edge. It has a noticeable Coconut scent instead of vanilla. Initially harsh, it becomes more pleasant over time.
Performance: Six-hour longevity with light, consistent projection.
Price: Best for those who want a close replica at a budget price.
Tommy Bahama St. Barts
Price: $20 – $72 USD
Bottle Sizes: 100mL
Top Notes: Lime, Tequila, Sea Notes, Agave
Middle Notes: Salt, Guava, Green Notes
Base Notes: Palm Leaf, Vanilla, Musk
Scent Profile: The smell of fresh-cut lime and tequila is immediately present in St. Barts. Although the lime isn’t entirely authentic, it remains bright, zesty, and tart.
Unlike Virgin Island Water, which excels in its Coconut scent, St. Barts offers a salty aquatic background with semi-sweet vanilla mimicking Coconut.
Performance: Lasts around four hours, ideal for summer.
Price: The most affordable option, offering a tropical vacation vibe.
Tips for Choosing the Right Clone
When selecting a dupe, consider the scent profile, performance (longevity and sillage), and price. These factors will help you find the perfect alternative that suits your preferences and budget.
These clones are excellent alternatives to Creed Virgin Island Water without the hefty price.
Whether you prefer a fragrance that leans more citrusy or one that emphasizes tropical notes, there’s a perfect dupe out there for everyone.
FAQs
Q: Are these clones as long-lasting as the original?
A: Most clones offer impressive longevity, though it varies. Gorse and Hawaii Volcano, for instance, last seven hours or more.
Q: Can these clones be worn year-round?
A: These fragrances are best suited for summer due to their tropical scent profiles.
Let Us Know
Have you tried any of these clones? Share your experiences and recommendations in the comments below! Your feedback helps others make informed decisions.
Tommy Bahama St Barts is my going to the beach fragrance. The lime is phony as a three dollar bill but the overall scent is pleasant enough esp for the price. That said, VIW is one of my going out for dinner scents along with Le Beau Le Parfum. Malibu Party in the Bay smells like vanilla play dough and not in a good way. It’s the only sample that I’ve ever thrown away.
That’s a great choice for the beach! I wish the lime wasn’t so synthetic but overall the blend of notes is interesting